Una din probleme ridicate de un fotograf in devenire este invadarea intimitatii subiectului. Mai jos sunt cateva cuvinte interesante despre acest subiect.
“Maya Ying Lin’s Viet Nam War Memorial was new at the time, and had been controversial. Lots of people at first felt it wasn’t sufficiently monumental, or not sufficiently figurative, or just too “arty.” Then, gradually, in what is almost a vindication story of the power of real art, people began to discover the Wall’s surprising potential for great emotional impact. It was a place where veterans gathered, families came to see names, and friends came to visit the names of missing friends?or simply where people went to reflect on life and death and war and peace. People left notes and mementos, which I believe the Park Service respectfully collects and archives. It’s just a surprisingly moving place. I visited it occasionally with my camera, in the course of my peregrinations around Washington.
Then, one day, one of those magical moment happened. It was the middle of a weekday and there were almost no people at the Wall. But as I entered from one end I became aware of a milling group ahead in the middle distance. A man was setting up a camera on a tripod. As I watched, an elderly gentleman was helped out of his wheelchair and walked to the Wall in the company of his wife. While this happened, the rest of what must have been a large extended family lined up to watch, in a big semi-circle. Many of them were crying, or had their hands to their mouths. As I watched, the two elderly people raised their hands and pointed to one name, obviously that of a dead son, and the man at the camera bent down to take their picture.
It was just one of those moments when the world resolves itself perfectly. The whole family had been on the far side of the man with the camera, so no one was standing in my way; and I was standing at the perfect distance for my lens to take in the whole scene?the Wall, the family, the two old people pointing, the empty wheelchair, the man bending down to record the moment; everything was presented to the camera as perfectly as if I had hired actors and staged it. It told a complete story. And I was in just the right position. I still feel that if I merely raised my camera and took just one shot, it would have run on the front page of the Washington Post the next day.
But I didn’t take the picture. It just seemed wrong, somehow. I had stopped walking toward the group, and stood there waiting, out of that reflexive sense of politeness we all feel in not wanting to intrude on others. To start snapping pictures of the whole group of strangers seemed to me like it would have been presumptuous. It just felt to me like it wasn’t my moment, is all. It was their moment, a private family moment, that just happened to be taking place out in public because that’s where the Wall was.
The picture that arranged itself in front of me disappeared as quickly as it had appeared. The man took his record shot, the father was helped back to his wheelchair, the family which had lined up so perfectly atomized into smaller groups. The moment was gone, except from my memory. Too late, by then, to reconsider.
I admit that in years since, I’ve regretted my reaction. I do wish I’d taken that picture. But that was definitely the day that my ambitions to be a photojournalist ended. There are some things we are and some things we aren’t; I’ll never sky-dive, or do a bad audition on American Idol just to get on TV. It’s just not who I am. And whatever else it does or doesn’t take, photojournalism requires a burning drive to get the shot?you need to have a certain boldness, a higher loyalty to getting the picture than to acting with the utmost civility. It’s just the name of that game. In the pinch, in the heat of that moment, when I was presented with maybe a 30-second window when I had to choose whether to shoot or act respectfully, it was more important for me to be respectful of that family’s privacy. I didn’t really plan it, and I can’t really take it back. It’s just who I am, I guess.
Iarna la munte marea de nori este un fenomen ce desparte inaltimile albastre, inzapezite ale muntilor de vaile lor gri si intunecate acoperite de nori. Jos totul e trist si doarme dar sus, deasupra norilor, festinul solar se dezvaluie cu bucuria si culoarea apusului de vara la malul marii.
(langa Arieseni… decembrie 2007)
We are happy to inform you that your photo Vinga will be displayed
together with your last three uploads on our start page http://www.fotocommunity.com
between 08:00 and 10:00.
Here’s the link to your photo:
Copilaria mi-am petrecut-o la tara… Cu sunetul ultimului clopotel eram deja nerabdator sa ajung la bunici, in satul Covasint. Cred ca anii de atunci m-au lasat cu o dragoste mare de natura… Si cum va spuneam, verile le petreceam la Covasint balacindu-ma in paraul din fata casei sau ducand caprele la pascut impreuna cu Mircea pe dealuri, jucand fotbal cu baietii in fata casei lui Dorin. In iernile geroase ma plimbam cu sania pe aceasi vale, pe aceasi strada, locuri de basm, asa ramase la mine in amintire.
Acum multi ani bunicii au vandut casa si s-au mutat la oras iar eu nu am mai fost acolo decat o singura data. Am ajuns intr-o primavara noroioasa. Nimic nu mai arata ca in amintirile mele, satul era sufocat de case mari, adevarate palate neterminate ale romilor stabiliti acolo. Strada mea era urata si rece iar valea murdara asemeni unei scurgeri de periferie urbana.
De atunci n-am mai trecut prin sat.
Vineri a fost o zi superba! Bruma, zapada, ceata si soare, o zi curata si geroasa, o zi ideala pentru fotograful impatimit de natura. Am iesit devreme la pozat pe dealurile din jurul Aradului. Pe drumul de intoarcere, drum ce trece prin sat, ceva m-a facut sa ma opresc. Am trecut din nou pe strada mea si iat-o! Acoperita de zapada strada era frumoasa si luminoasa ca albul de basm al iernilor de demult. Dintr-o data amintirile au renascut vii in sufletul meu.
Bucuros nevoie mare si anuntat galagios de cainii vecinilor de prin curti, am inceput sa fotografiez locurile. Nu i-am bagat in seama. La un moment dat insa cineva ma striga. Ma intorc. Doua doamne de varsta mijlocie, bine imbracate, treceau podul peste vale indreptandu-se spre mine.
– Buna ziua!
– Buna! Ce faceti, filmati?
– Nu! Doar fac poze aici pe strada! Este asa o zi frumoasa si satul e frumos!
– Da sunteti neamt? ma intreaba una. Numele meu de familie este Neamtu asa ca am zambit. Probabil credeau ca sunt roman plecat in Germania…
– Nu nu sunt neamt…
– Da sunteti de pe aici? doamnele deschise si cu chef de vorba, asa ca, dupa un moment de ezitare, le spun:
– Da. Sunt de aici. Am copilarit in casa aia. Sunt baiatul lui Neamtu.
– A, da, ne amintim de domnul si doamna Neamtu. Oameni cu stare. Au plecat la oras, demult.
– Da, au plecat, s-au mutat cu parintii mei ca sa le fie mai aproape.
M-am bucurat ca bunicii mei au ramas cunoscuti in sat dupa atata vreme si ca am cunoscut pe doamnele astea de treaba. Le zambesc. Imi zambesc si ele inapoi si una zice:
– Auzi, da n-ai sa ne dai ceva bani? Sa cumparam si noi de mancare la copii???!!!
Le-am dat. Intr-un veritabil reset la concret, blocat complet de replica lor.
So keres, Europa?